Beeminder vs StickK vs Remindeeu: Best Commitment App Compared
ยท 7 min read
Short answer: Beeminder suits people who love tracking numbers. StickK suits people motivated by a referee or anti charity. Remindeeu suits people who want simple milestone check ins, a clear penalty rule that resets, reminders, a 7 day pause and a group of fellow stakers.
Putting money on a goal is one of the most researched ways to change behavior. These three apps do it differently.
Comparison
| Beeminder | StickK | Remindeeu | |
|---|---|---|---|
| How you report | Data points on a graph | Self or referee report | Dot each milestone |
| Penalty | Escalating pledges | Fixed stake | Grows per default, paid on third, then resets |
| Minimum stake | Varies | Varies | $5 |
| Pause | Take a break feature | Limited | Up to 7 days |
| Future self message | No | No | Yes |
| Community | Forum | Community pages | Stakers group chat plus private messages |
How Remindeeu stakes work
- Set your goal, deadline and promise.
- Add dotting milestones.
- Stake at least $5 and choose your penalty per default (at least $2).
- Miss a dot and the penalty grows. On the third default the total goes to Mr. Remindeeu and resets to $0.
- On your deadline, your future self message lands in your inbox.
Which goals suit each tool
- Daily numeric habits such as steps, pages or minutes practiced: Beeminder handles these well if you enjoy logging data.
- One big outcome with a referee, such as quitting smoking by a date: StickK fits.
- Milestone goals such as finishing the Bible this year, exam reading or a savings plan: Remindeeu dots map directly to the milestones.
What happens when you slip
Slips are where commitment apps succeed or fail. A penalty that feels unfair makes people quit the app entirely. Remindeeu keeps each penalty step small and resets the counter after the third default, so you pay a real cost without feeling the whole goal is lost. A 7 day pause covers illness and travel, and your upcoming dots move with it so pausing never creates defaults.
Verdict
Love numbers: Beeminder. Want a referee or anti charity: StickK. Want something simple you set up once, with reminders and people beside you: Remindeeu.
FAQ
Is putting money on a goal effective?
Research on commitment devices suggests people are more likely to follow through when they choose a meaningful cost for failing. The key is choosing an amount that matters to you without causing hardship.
Can I change my penalty later?
On Remindeeu you can raise your penalty per default at any time from the goal page.